TALK_WHILE_MUTED is not getting triggered

mcmohd · August 14, 2020, 9:26pm

Hi I’m trying to detect if someone is speaking while mic is off and tried to setup the event as follows:

But unfortunately its not getting triggered. Kindly suggest if there is anyway which I can try?

 room.addEventListener(JitsiMeetJS.events.conference.TALK_WHILE_MUTED, () => {
        console.log( "You look like on mute...." );
});

mcmohd · August 15, 2020, 3:47pm

I have tried it all the way but there is no even getting triggered while I’m in mute but speaking…

room.addEventListener(JitsiMeetJS.events.track.TALK_WHILE_MUTED, () => {
console.log( “You look like on mute…” );
});

corby · August 17, 2020, 6:35pm

Make sure enableTalkWhileMuted is set to true in your config. Learn how to do this here:

mcmohd · August 17, 2020, 9:56pm

I already have done this setup but still there is no event getting triggered. I’m sure there is some other setting which I’m missing.

mcmohd · August 19, 2020, 8:48am

I tried to debug it and following is the findings:

Its giving warning that we ddid not provide a VAD processor so no voice detection service will be provided.

No VAD Processor was provided. Talk while muted detection service was

Now after going through further documentation of the JITSI, we have a function where we need to pass an object and that object should implement few functions to process the voice specially the function calculateAudioFrameVAD(pcmSample) is complex one.

JitsiMeetJS.createTrackVADEmitter

This is a bit strange for me…Not sure if there is something else to make [TALK_WHILE_MUTED ], then please correct me otherwise its something like digging a well to drink the water…

mcmohd · August 20, 2020, 7:00am

I’m wondering about this community who is not willing even to look into others problem, everyone is asking his own questions…we ask our questions ourself do R&D ourself and find a solution ourself, JITSI developers are busy in their own world, they reply to a set of predefined people only…Anyway…

corby · August 20, 2020, 9:16am

What’s in your interface config? What’s in your other config.js? What version of Prosody do you have?

By the way this is a community for us. The developers are really busy and do not have time to read or respond to everything.

mcmohd · August 20, 2020, 9:21am

Thanks Corby for reply.

I’m using lib-jitsi-meet and TALK_WHILE_MUTED and NOISY MiC DETECTION are not triggering. I have tried all the way by setting enableTalkWhileMuted and tried capturing it in the following listener

conferenece.addEventListener(JitsiMeetJS.events.track.TALK_WHILE_MUTED, () => {
console.log( “You look like on mute…” );
});

If I turned on WARN messages, its giving following message:

No VAD Processor was provided. Talk while muted detection service was

Now I’m not sure how I can write VAD Processor…

corby · August 20, 2020, 9:24am

Is this on Safari? If so, it looks like it’s disabled on Safari:

github.com

jitsi/lib-jitsi-meet/blob/3ac82faa2d6a0e09428b89409b1c89cce08904bf/JitsiConference.js#L391


        this.statistics.attachLongTasksStats(this);
    }
}

this.eventManager.setupChatRoomListeners();

// Always add listeners because on reload we are executing leave and the
// listeners are removed from statistics module.
this.eventManager.setupStatisticsListeners();

// Disable VAD processing on Safari since it causes audio input to
// fail on some of the mobile devices.
if (config.enableTalkWhileMuted && !browser.isSafari()) {

    // If VAD processor factory method is provided uses VAD based detection, otherwise fallback to audio level
    // based detection.
    if (config.createVADProcessor) {
        logger.info('Using VAD detection for generating talk while muted events');

        if (!this._audioAnalyser) {
            this._audioAnalyser = new VADAudioAnalyser(this, config.createVADProcessor);

Actually. A few lines below that show the error you see: https://github.com/jitsi/lib-jitsi-meet/blob/3ac82faa2d6a0e09428b89409b1c89cce08904bf/JitsiConference.js#L411

mcmohd · August 20, 2020, 9:43am

No I’m using Google Chrome, and as mentioned in the code, it won’t even display warning message if it won’t go inside, it is going inside when enableTalkWhileMuted is set to true and it is not Safari. So it is going inside but its getting stuck at config.createVADProcessor which I believe we can’t provide from outside because in documentation as well, there is no any parameter given with a name createVADProcessor.

corby · August 20, 2020, 10:09am

Have you tried on https://jit.si using the same browser and setting enableTalkWhileMuted in the URL?

I can tell you both mute and noise options do work. (just tested). I’m wondering if there is an issues with your hardware? First try on jit.si and then, if possible, maybe try a different computer on your site.

mcmohd · August 20, 2020, 11:55am

Yes they work perfectly fine in JITSI MEET, but looks like they are not available in JISTI LIB.

sowmya_subramaniam · October 22, 2020, 7:04am

Has there been any advancement in this? I too am using lib-jitsi-meet. I have been facing the same issue.
Best.

mcmohd · October 27, 2020, 4:21am

Sorry there is no progress.

jenriellegaon · December 5, 2020, 5:40am

Hi ! I am also waiting for this to be fixed. NOISY_MIC and TALK_WHILE_MUTED is not working even if you enable “enableTalkWhileMuted”

mcmohd · March 25, 2021, 11:30am

Dear Friends,

Any progress someone made on this feature?

Please help.